It’s all in your head

June 6, 2010 § 3 Comments

I’ve been reading Stephen Pinker’s book “The Blank Slate” slowly over the past few months, and it’s a fantastic read. The main premise is that the idea of the mind when formed as a “blank slate” is an antiquated and incorrect supposition. He goes on to show how the brain’s neural network actually has a certain amount of “programming” in it at birth with regards to what parts of the brain do what function. Obviously things like breathing are in there too, but some less obvious traits are present at birth also. This is not a book review of “The Blank Slate” however I do highly recommend it, and Pinker’s writing is very easy to digest.

Since I started reading this book I have had an increasing interest in what parts of our lives are driven by the brain, and what parts are more physical. I read an article recently about near-death-experiences, and how studies have shown that these experiences of moving into a light, floating away from their own bodies or some other “spiritual” experience is caused by a massive surge of electrical impulses as the body dies, or almost dies. This makes perfect sense to me, we must experience something in the last moments of our lives, and those who have teetered over the edge of death only to be revived seem able to recall what must be a very stressful and traumatic event.

This apparent “spiritual” experience was also the subject of a friend’s blog piece titled “Getting Off Your Face for Jesus” which suggests that the spiritual is a lot more about chemical reactions in the brain than anything metaphysical. I’d tend to agree with this, as the way I understand it everything we experience is by way of chemical/neural interactions in the brain, including the so called “spiritual”. The environment interacts with the body, the body interacts with the brain and the outcome is the experience.

As I have mentioned in the past, people knowingly alter their states of consciousness in order to “attain enlightenment” or contact the “other world” or “spirit world”, by means of drugs, chanting, rituals, flagellation and any number of strange practices. It would seem that this altering of the normal brain activity causes us to feel as though our experiences are beyond the body.

I have seen first-hand what happens to someone who has a brain tumor, and the way it can cause not only visions but confusions about the visions too. When the brain stops functioning how it should strange things happen. In this particular case, a loved-one of mine had a tumor in the area of the brain which is attributed to sight, and she described sometimes seeing golden light emanating from people’s skins, and at to her times seeing bugs crawling around in her peripheral vision. This was all just a symptom of the undiagnosed tumor, but to her it was as if she was experiencing hell. In her case, as a Christian, her interpretations of what was happening to her related back to her faith to a certain degree.

It is interesting that given all our experiences are interpreted by the brain, it’s our reaction as a society to separate mind from body, and spirit from mind. We can prove that experiences can be fabricated by triggering parts of the brain, and sensations can be emulated by triggering others. Why do people find it so unlikely that the brain is what allows us to experience anything and everything, and rather attribute this to a higher being? As time goes on we understand more and more about the workings of the brain and eventually will be able to explain “spiritual” experiences better.


Tagged: , , , , , , , ,

§ 3 Responses to It’s all in your head

  • Andrea says:

    This made me think about the ‘nature/nurture’ debate. I always found myself on the side of nature, as I believe that people are who they are from a very young age, perhaps even from birth. I guess I came to this conclusion by simply observing siblings and noticing how very different some people can be, having been raised in the exact same manner.

    I haven’t read The blank slate so have no idea if this comes into it, but it sounds like an interesting read.

    This particular piece also made me remember the whole ’21 grams theory’….

  • DuckPhup says:

    “It is interesting that given all our experiences are interpreted by the brain…”

    It’s also interesting to consider that such interpretation takes place in the internalized ‘filters’ that make up our ‘self-description’…

    * misconceptions
    * prejudices
    * beliefs (the ILLUSION of knowledge)
    * knowledge-base
    * experiential reference

    Cleanup of those ‘filters’ is a primary task in personal development… one that is entirely omitted in most of humanity, particularly the ‘religious’. Where we should be focused on tearing down the first three of those filters, followed by recapitulation of the last two… ‘religion’ is devoted to building up misconceptions, prejudices and beliefs.

  • […] Atheist Climber Making Sense « It’s all in your head […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading It’s all in your head at Atheist Climber.


%d bloggers like this: